Opens in a new tab

How to not get burned by a web design agency

Most business owners commission a website once every few years, so they go into it with little to compare against. Agencies have pitched hundreds of times and know which answers reassure.

That’s how business owners end up paying for a site that looks good but brings in no work.

Written by

Paul Croft

Published on

SEO, Website design
The questions to ask a web design agency before you sign
Paul Croft

Comparing quotes?

Send us the details and we’ll tell you what it covers, what’s missing and which questions to ask before you sign.

This guide covers the 13 pitfalls we see most often, in the order you’re likely to meet them. Each one comes with a question to ask, what a good answer sounds like, and the warning signs. Take the questions with you to your next agency call.

Before you talk to an agency

The first two are questions for you. Answer them before you contact anyone and you’ll be much harder to sell to.

1. Rebuilding when you don’t need to

A new website is the answer most people reach for when enquiries dry up, but the problem is often smaller than that. It might be a confusing menu, a contact button buried in the footer, or a homepage that never gives anyone a reason to choose you. Those can be fixed on the site you already have, for a fraction of the cost.

A small law firm came to us feeling their WordPress site no longer reflected the business. Rather than rebuilding, we refreshed their logo and updated their existing theme. While we were doing that, we found their main service pages gave visitors no clear next step, such as a button to get in touch. Adding one to each page increased enquiries by 20%.

Ask yourself: What isn’t working on my current site, and how do I know?

A good answer: You can name specific problems, such as few enquiries or visitors leaving the contact page, and you have some evidence for them.

Watch out for: The only reason being “it looks dated”, or an agency recommending a rebuild before it has looked properly at the site you have.

If you can’t tell what’s wrong, a website audit will show you what needs fixing and whether a rebuild is worth the money.

2. Not knowing what the site is for

Most business owners we work with haven’t thought about this until we ask. It’s easy to skip, because you know your business so well that the answer feels obvious. Then we ask who exactly the site is for, and what that person needs to hear before they get in touch, and it turns out to be harder to pin down than expected.

Our discovery questionnaires start here, because every decision after it depends on the answer. If you don’t decide who the site is for and what it should do, the agency will decide for you, usually based on what will look good in their portfolio.

Ask yourself: What should a visitor do after reading my site, and who is that visitor?

A good answer: One or two clear actions, such as calling or booking a consultation, and a clear picture of the clients you want more of.

Watch out for: Struggling to answer, or an agency that starts talking about design before it has asked who your clients are.

Choosing the agency

3. The people you meet aren’t the people who build it

In many agencies, the person who pitches to you is a director or salesperson, and the work goes to a junior designer or a freelancer you never speak to. That can work well, but you should know about it before you sign.

It’s also worth knowing where your fee goes. Larger agencies carry larger overheads, such as offices and account managers, so part of a higher quote may be paying for those rather than for work on your site.

Ask: Who will plan, write, design and build my site, and will I deal with them directly?

A good answer: Names and roles, and direct contact with the people doing the work.

Watch out for: “Our team” with no names, or work handed to someone else without telling you.

4. A portfolio that shows looks, not results

An agency portfolio is chosen to look good, and it rarely shows whether those sites did anything for the businesses that paid for them. Design awards tend to be judged on how a site looks, so they tell you little about whether it brings in work.

Ask: Can you show me a live site you built and tell me what changed for that business afterwards?

A good answer: Live sites you can click around and specific outcomes such as more enquiries or better-fit clients.

Watch out for: Screenshots and awards offered as proof.

The process

This is where agencies differ most, and it’s the hardest part to judge from a sales call. These questions help you find out how a project will run before you’ve paid for one.

5. Design before content

Many agencies design the pages first, fill them with placeholder text, then ask you for copy to fit the spaces. It feels like progress because you see something early. The trouble starts when the real copy doesn’t fit. Either your message gets cut down to suit the layout, or the pages get redesigned and you pay for the work twice.

Planning the content first avoids this. Before anyone opens a design tool, you decide what each page needs to say, who it’s for and what you want the reader to do next. The design is then built to present that.

Check who’s writing the words for your website pages. Many quotes assume you will, and plenty of business owners only find this out halfway through the project.

Ask: Who writes or plans the copy, and when does that happen?

A good answer: The messaging and page content are planned before design starts, and the quote says who is writing it.

Watch out for: “Send us your text when it’s ready”, or copywriting listed as an optional extra.

6. No plan before design

A wireframe shows how each page is laid out before any design is added. Most agencies make them as flat images. We build ours as real web pages, with your copy in place, but no colour and placeholder photos. You can click through them in your browser and check the structure works, without the design getting in the way.

Agreeing the structure at this stage lets you fix problems while changes are cheap. Going straight to a polished homepage design impresses in a meeting, but once you’ve approved something that looks finished, structural problems cost more to put right.

Ask: Will I see and approve the page structure before any visual design starts?

A good answer: A sitemap and wireframes for you to sign off first, ideally ones you can view as web pages with your real content in place.

Watch out for: The first thing you’re shown being a finished-looking homepage.

7. SEO that is only a word

We rebuilt the website for a local dog trainer who had already had a quote from another agency. SEO wasn’t mentioned anywhere in it. When the owner pushed, the agency said the website “will include SEO” and left it there.

There was no keyword research, no look at local competitors, and nothing to suggest anyone had considered how people find a dog trainer. For a local business where a lot of new clients start with a search, that was a major gap.

How much SEO you need depends on how your clients find you. If people search for what you do, the site should be planned around those searches, which means finding the words people use, seeing what local competitors rank for, and deciding which pages you need as a result.

If most of your work comes through referrals, a sound technical setup may be enough, and a good agency will tell you that.

Ask: What does your SEO work involve, and what will I receive?

A good answer: Specific deliverables, such as keyword research and a page plan built from it, and an honest view of how much search matters for your business.

Watch out for: SEO only mentioned when you ask, “SEO is included” with no detail, or guaranteed rankings.

8. Losing search traffic at launch

However tired your current site looks, it probably brings in some visitors from Google. Each page has an address that search engines know about.

If the new site moves or renames those pages without redirects, which send visitors from old addresses to the right new ones, people following old links and search results land on error pages.

Avoiding this takes a few hours of planning before launch, so it’s worth asking about early.

Ask: How will you protect the traffic my current site already gets?

A good answer: A list of the current pages that bring in visitors, a plan for redirecting old addresses to new ones, and checks in the weeks after launch.

Watch out for: A blank look, or “Google will pick it up”.

The contract

9. You don’t own what you paid for

An agency may register your domain in its own name or keep the admin logins, which seems harmless until you want to leave or the agency closes. Your domain is your web address and often your email too, so losing control of it causes real problems.

Ask: Who will own the domain, hosting account, website and content, and will I have full admin access?

A good answer: Everything registered in your name, with full logins handed over at launch.

Watch out for: The domain registered to the agency, or being told you don’t need admin access.

10. You can’t leave

Some agencies build on their own platform or insist your site stays on their hosting, which ties you to their prices and service.

Ask: If we part ways, can I take the site elsewhere, and what would that involve?

A good answer: Yes, with the files and logins handed over and no exit fee.

Watch out for: Hosting you have to keep with them, or a fee to release the site.

11. A vague scope

Many disagreements in web projects come down to what was included. A short quote feels simple at the start, but it leaves room for arguments later, usually about revisions and extras.

Payment terms matter too. Paying in stages linked to milestones means you only pay for work you’ve seen.

We offer a discount for paying in full up front, as do some other agencies, and that’s fine when it’s your choice.

Ask: What exactly is included, how many rounds of changes do I get, how are extra changes priced, and what are the payment options?

A good answer: A written scope, a set number of revision rounds, a clear process for changes, and staged payments tied to milestones, with any alternative offered as your choice.

Watch out for: A one-line quote, full payment required up front with no alternative, or no mention of what happens if the project stalls.

After launch

12. Costs that start after launch

Hosting, updates, security and the occasional fix all cost money once a site is live, and that’s normal. The problem comes when those costs aren’t mentioned until handover, or arrive as a monthly package with a long minimum term.

Ask: What will this cost me each year after launch, and what does that cover?

A good answer: Hosting, updates, security and support listed with prices, and clear terms on how long you’re committed for.

Watch out for: A retainer that appears at handover, or a long minimum contract.

13. No way to tell if it’s working

Without figures from before and after launch, you can’t tell whether the new site is doing better than the old one, and you’re left judging it on how it looks.

Analytics should be set up. We give each client their own dashboard, so they can see visits and enquiries for themselves.

Ask: How will we know whether the new site is doing its job?

A good answer: Analytics set up before launch, and a review after a few months.

Watch out for: Measurement not mentioned until you raise it.

Before you sign

Most of these questions take a minute to ask. A good agency will answer them easily and put the important answers in writing.

If you’re comparing quotes and would like a second opinion, get in touch.